What Happens When Customers Trust Online Reviews Less?
Imagine you need someone to repair a damaged fence. One company has hundreds of glowing reviews, many written in nearly identical language. Another has fewer reviews, but people describe how the crew handled specific jobs. You also recognize its name from a local venue and a neighbor mentions seeing its truck nearby. Which company would you feel comfortable calling first?
Online reviews still give customers a way to compare businesses. The change worth paying attention to is how confidently they rely on strangers’ recommendations relative to advice from people they know. A local business can make the decision easier by giving customers several independent ways to check what it actually does. A place-based ad can introduce the business, reviews can describe real experiences and the business itself can supply details customers can verify.
What changed in how people weigh reviews?
BrightLocal’s U.S. Local Consumer Review Survey asked whether people trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations from friends and family. Its 2025 report put that figure at 42%, compared with 79% in its 2020 report. The 2025 survey used a representative panel of 1,026 U.S. adults. This was a comparison of survey editions, with different respondents, on one question about relative trust. It gives no direct measure of the number of fake reviews or the effect of a particular platform.
BrightLocal’s 2026 report still describes reviews as an important part of researching businesses and notes a wider mix of sources, including video and AI tools. Taken together, the findings point to a customer who may consult more kinds of information before making a decision. A person can think reviews are useful, read several of them and still decide to check a friend’s recommendation or look for photos of recent work.
This is where a business can make a practical difference. If customers repeatedly ask whether you handle a certain type of job, put the answer on your service page and show an example. If they ask how much notice you need, make your booking window clear. These details give people something to check when a general endorsement leaves them unsure.
Why a specific account carries more weight than a star rating
A five-star rating says somebody was satisfied. A review explaining that a shop found a replacement part, called when it arrived and returned the repaired bike before a weekend ride helps the next customer judge whether that shop might suit them. The same is true of a restaurant review that describes a large group booking or a café review that mentions access with a stroller. A customer can recognize their own situation in the story.
Businesses can ask for honest feedback after a real interaction. A bike shop might send its usual follow-up after pickup and invite the customer to share whatever would help the next person make a decision. A repair company could ask whether its instructions for looking after the repair were clear. Customers should be free to describe things that could have gone better. The business gains something useful when people explain both what worked and where they got confused.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission’s 2024 rule addresses specified deceptive practices involving reviews and testimonials, including fake reviews, buying reviews conditioned on a particular sentiment and certain failures to disclose insider relationships. For a business owner, the everyday takeaway is to build a review process around genuine experiences. When uncertain about a particular promotion or testimonial arrangement, check the FTC rule and the rules of the platform you plan to use.
A screen ad can make a business easier to check out
A paid placement has a different job from a customer review. It can show the business’s name and a recognizable example of its work in a place that potential customers already visit. A review can then tell a reader what it was like to book the service or resolve a problem. If both lead to an accurate business profile and a helpful website, the person has enough information to decide whether to take the next step.
Suppose a local bicycle shop wants people to know it does commuter tune-ups. It might show a real workbench, name the shop and point people to a short service page. There, visitors can see where the shop is, learn what the tune-up includes and check the latest booking information. Someone watching the screen can remember the shop and search for it later, even if they were in the middle of a conversation when it ran.
There is a distinction between being seen in a community and being endorsed by it. A paid spot inside a café says the business purchased space there. If the café has a personal experience with the shop and wants to share it, ask permission and make any commercial relationship clear. A customer can assign the right weight to each piece of evidence when the business is clear about where it came from.
Make it easy to compare evidence across channels
Most customers do not follow the same route every time. One may see an ad and go straight to Maps. Another may ask a colleague for a name and look up recent reviews after dinner. A third may need to see photos before feeling comfortable requesting an estimate. Build each piece to answer the question a customer is likely to have when they get there.
| What the customer is trying to find out | What helps them check |
|---|---|
| Is this a real business near me? | A complete business profile, consistent contact details and recognizable photos |
| Can it handle a job like mine? | A recent project example and a clear explanation of what is included |
| What has the experience been like for other people? | Detailed reviews from actual customers and thoughtful public responses |
| How do I reach the right person? | A clear next step, current hours and a working phone number or booking page |
Pay attention to how you respond when a review describes a problem. A brief reply can tell the next reader who to contact and what the business can do about it. Keep personal details out of the public exchange and use the same tone you would at the counter. For example, if parking was confusing during a street closure, add current directions to your listing and let the reviewer know where people can now park. That gives future customers an actionable detail even if they never read the full exchange.
A practical test is to follow your own ad like a customer. Search the name exactly as it appears on screen. Open your listing and check the photographs, hours and contact information. Then make sure the webpage actually explains whatever the creative promised. If your screen mentions same-week appointments and your booking page only says “contact us,” use clearer wording on the site or change the ad to match what customers can do.
This also applies to reviews received through existing channels. Read a few recent ones and see which details people are already willing to share without prompting. If several reviewers mention that someone answered a weekend call, customers are learning something operational about the business. Show your phone hours clearly and make sure that anyone covering the line knows what can be booked. The best evidence comes from a service the business can continue to deliver.
Start with the gap that causes people to hesitate
An independent business may be short of customer feedback because it rarely asks for it. It may already have useful feedback but no recent photographs. It may have a good profile and reviews but still be unfamiliar outside a small circle of regulars. Putting every business through the same plan wastes time. Identify what a careful customer would still need to know before calling you.
Ask a few recent customers what helped them decide and what almost stopped them. If several mention that they were unsure whether you served their town, update your service-area information. If they wanted to meet someone or see the work, add an accurate photo or a short example. If they heard the name from friends but other people in the area seemed unfamiliar with it, a campaign in relevant venues might help introduce it to a wider audience.
Measure what changed in a way that fits the question. A new service page can be tracked through qualified inquiries. A screen campaign might be tracked with a short link and a simple question when people contact you. If someone says they saw your name in a venue but decided after reading reviews, record both. One channel introduced you and the other helped them get comfortable. That sequence is useful when deciding where to invest next.
For people weighing a purchase, a recognizable name is often only the beginning. Make it easy to find an honest account, look at real work and get a straight answer. The combination is stronger because customers can decide what to make of each piece for themselves. See how Sunview places ads in local venues.
Sources and methodology
- BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2025. Used for the 2025 result and BrightLocal’s comparison with its 2020 report. The figures reflect stated trust relative to personal recommendations. Survey findings
- BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026. Used for the ongoing role of reviews and the wider mix of research channels. Survey findings
- Federal Trade Commission, Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (2024). Used to identify the practices the rule addresses. Rule and supporting materials